Project Bankability: What Lenders Need to See in an Energy Project

A bankable energy project is one a lender will finance because its risks can be identified, priced and assigned to parties able to carry them. It is not the same as a project with a good return. Bankability is decided by contracts, counterparties, technical evidence and a financial model that holds under stress, and it is built long before a lender sees the deal. At Sharon Creek Ventures, we work on that build from the founder's side of the table, on complex projects in nuclear, woody waste-to-fuel and agricultural waste-to-fuel.

Project Finance

Editorial image for “Project Bankability: What Lenders Need to See in an Energy Project”

TL;DR

  • Bankability is the ability to attract financing from a lender. Lenders in project finance look to the project's own cash flows, so every risk to those cash flows has to be visibly allocated.
  • A profitable project can still fail the test. Strong IRR does not replace enforceable offtake, creditworthy counterparties and committed equity.
  • Funders ask for feasibility work, a credible financial model, sponsor equity and a track record. IRENA reports that 45% of projects submitted to one financing facility are rejected for low readiness.
  • New technology adds the hardest barrier: lenders will not take the risk that it fails to perform to commercial standards over the loan's life.
  • Close the gaps while the project is still cheap to change, before you approach lenders.

Table of Contents

What bankability means in project finance

A U.S. Department of Commerce training presentation on power project financing describes bankability as the ability to attract financing from a lender, whether a commercial bank, a development finance institution or a private equity fund. That is a practical definition. It says nothing about whether the idea is good. It asks only whether someone with money will lend against it.

The reason the bar is specific comes from how project finance works. A DOE-commissioned study of clean-energy financing describes it as asset-based, limited-recourse financing, typically around 70% debt and 30% equity, where project revenue has to cover equity returns, debt interest and principal, transaction costs and operating and maintenance costs. Limited recourse means the lender cannot simply chase the sponsor's other assets if the project underperforms. The project has to repay the loan on its own.

That shifts what the lender studies. A corporate lender looks at a company's balance sheet. A project lender looks at a single asset, its contracts and its forecast, and asks what can go wrong between financial close and the last repayment.

What bankability means in project finance

Bankability, viability and financeability

Three words get mixed up, and the difference matters when you plan the work.

  • Viability asks whether the project makes economic sense: positive net present value, attractive returns, real demand.
  • Bankability asks whether the structure is acceptable to lenders: contracts, risk allocation, counterparties, security.
  • Financeability is the practical outcome: can this project actually close financing on terms its sponsors can accept.

A viable project can be unbankable if its only revenue is a forecast and not a contract. We cover the related idea of financeability in more depth in what makes an energy project financeable.

What lenders test before they commit

Lenders do not invent their own checklist each time. The same questions come up across banks, export credit agencies and government loan programs. Here is how they group.

Revenue that is contracted and predictable

The Commerce presentation names the power purchase agreement (PPA, the long-term contract under which a buyer takes the project's output) as the key document for establishing bankability. The terms it highlights are contract term, tariff, change-in-law and tax treatment, offtaker creditworthiness, sponsor quality, billing and payment, currency, termination, remedies and lenders' rights. DOE's renewable-energy financing briefing says the same from the lender's side: the project agreement is the critical document, and risk allocation must reflect the relationship between the parties without loading so much risk onto the seller that it undermines the investment.

The buyer matters as much as the contract. A strong agreement with a weak counterparty is only as good as that counterparty's ability to pay. Where the offtaker is thin, credit support comes in two forms, per the same presentation: liquidity support such as escrow accounts and liquidity letters of credit, and termination support such as government guarantees or put-and-call options.

Evidence the project can be built and run

The U.S. Export-Import Bank (EXIM) publishes what it expects in a project finance application. Its guidelines for a successful application call for completed feasibility studies, front-end engineering and design (FEED), an approved environmental and social impact assessment, a preliminary financing plan and an information memorandum with a detailed project management schedule. They also call for a management team that has developed similar bankable deals.

A financial model that survives scrutiny

EXIM asks for a model showing all project costs, sources and uses of capital, revenues, expenses, debt amortization and the resulting financial ratios. IRENA adds that investors value detailed models with sensitivity analysis and adjustments for currency and inflation. The point of sensitivity work is not to show a rosy base case. It is to show the lender where the debt still gets repaid when costs rise or output falls.

Equity that is committed, not promised

EXIM expects substantial committed sponsor equity covering capital costs, overruns and contingent needs. IRENA reports that investors typically expect an 80/20 debt-to-equity split for traditional renewables and more equity for riskier technologies. A thin equity layer is one of the fastest ways to lose a lender's attention.

Security and enforceability

Lenders also need to know what happens if things go wrong. They want an enforceable path to step in and recover value. A Wilson Sonsini primer on clean-tech project finance notes that lenders must be able to foreclose on project assets of sufficient value to make themselves whole. If the asset is highly specialized, with no obvious buyer, that comfort weakens.

Where energy projects fail the test

The DOE study by Goldman, McKenna and Murphy groups the barriers into four risks. They remain a useful frame even though the study dates from 2005, because the logic of lending has not changed.

Barrier What the lender worries about What tends to help
Technology risk The technology cannot perform to commercial standards over the project life Proven providers, performance guarantees, technology risk insurance
Credit-worthiness risk New technology with no testing, market acceptance or credit track record Strong sponsors, third-party guarantees, subordinated debt
Revenue-security risk Revenue is not secured over the capital payback period, for example a 15-year amortization Long-term offtake or PPA agreements
Market-competition risk Higher capital costs while revenue is capped by cheaper competing energy Monetizing tax benefits, interest-rate swaps and caps

The study's recommended responses include monetizing tax benefits in the financing plan, nontraditional insurance, subordinated debt, third-party loan guarantees and offtake agreements. EXIM's guidelines point the same way for new technology: proven providers and mitigants such as technology risk insurance.

For the founders and developers we work with, the pattern is familiar. The technology may be real, the demand may be real, and the project still stalls because one dependency is unresolved. A feedstock supply that is not contracted, an interconnection that is not secured, an offtaker that is not creditworthy. Lenders read the weakest dependency, not the strongest. We explore how that plays out for fuel projects in when feedstock variability becomes a financing risk and for batteries in which risk keeps grid-scale storage from becoming financeable.

How to raise bankability before you approach lenders

IRENA's April 2024 expert insight frames this as a set of pillars: project readiness, secured offtake, a financial model with sensitivity analysis, sponsor track record and risk management. Its sharpest figure comes from data on projects submitted for financing consideration: 45% are rejected for low readiness and 25% for poor financial planning, half of the latter for low equity levels. In other words, most rejections come from preparation gaps, not from bad ideas.

Here is a sequence that addresses those gaps in the order they tend to bite.

  1. Map every dependency. List each commercial, technical, regulatory and financial dependency the project needs to be built and operated: land, permits, interconnection, feedstock or fuel, technology supply, offtake, construction contractor, operator. Mark which are contracted, which are agreed in principle and which are open.
  2. Fix the offtake first. Revenue security drives everything downstream. Long-term PPAs or take-or-pay contracts with creditworthy buyers shape debt size and tenor. Where the buyer is weak, plan the credit support early.
  3. Allocate risk deliberately. Construction and performance risk generally belong with the parties who control them. The goal is that each risk sits with the party best able to manage it, and that the contracts say so in terms a lender can enforce.
  4. Finish the engineering and permitting work lenders will rely on. Feasibility, FEED and environmental approvals are not paperwork to be done at the end. They are the evidence base the lender's advisers will test.
  5. Build the model for the lender, not the pitch. Sources and uses, debt amortization, ratios, downside cases. Make sure every assumption traces to a document.
  6. Commit the equity and the team. Show who funds overruns, and show that the people leading the project have done something comparable.
  7. Then sequence the capital. Decide which instruments fit which stage: development capital, construction debt, government programs, insurance, guarantees.

The step most teams skip is the first. Founders often know their own technology deeply and discover a missing dependency only when a lender's counsel asks for it. Our view is that the dependency map is the project's real plan, and we describe the stages in more depth in renewable project development: stages, risks and financing.

Government capital as a bridge for first-of-a-kind projects

For projects whose technology lacks a long commercial record, private lenders can be slow to engage. In the United States, the Department of Energy's Loan Programs Office (LPO) was designed with this gap in mind. Its Bridge to Bankability materials from April 2022 say LPO derisks breakthrough projects and technologies at early stages of commercialization so they can reach full market acceptance.

Per LPO's October 2023 overview of Title 17 clean energy financing:

  • Loans have no minimum or maximum size, up to 80% of eligible project costs.
  • LPO offers 100% guarantees of Treasury Federal Financing Bank loans or partial guarantees up to 90% of commercial loans.
  • Tenor can run up to 30 years.
  • There is no application fee, a facility fee of 0.6% on the first $2.0 billion at financial close (0.1% above that), and an annual maintenance fee.

Terms and program rules change with law and policy, so treat those figures as the October 2023 published terms and confirm the current ones with LPO.

The application path is staged. According to the April 2022 materials, it starts with no-fee pre-application consultations, then a Part I application testing technical eligibility, then an invited Part II application testing project viability, followed by confirmatory due diligence and term-sheet negotiation. LPO's eligibility criteria include a U.S. location, significant and credible greenhouse gas or air-pollution reductions, a reasonable prospect of repayment, technically viable and commercially ready technology, and a Community Benefits Plan. The applicant pays third-party advisor costs.

Two lessons follow. A federal program does not lower the bar on repayment: "reasonable prospect of repayment" is a bankability test by another name. And the application rewards a team that arrives with its dependencies mapped and its model built.

What this means by reader

Founders and developers. Treat bankability as a design constraint from the first term sheet. Choose technology, siting and offtake structure with the lender's questions in mind, because changing them after the engineering is done is expensive.

Boards. The board's job is to make sure the project's open dependencies are known, owned and dated. A board that sees a bankability gap list each quarter makes better capital decisions than one that sees only a schedule.

Investors and family offices. Bankability is also your diligence screen. If a project's revenue is a forecast, its risks are unallocated or its equity is uncommitted, the returns on the slide deck are not the returns you will earn.

Nuclear and first-of-a-kind developers. The technology barrier is the one that takes longest to retire. Counterparty strength, power contract structure and developer financial stability become central, a theme we take up in assessing advanced reactor developer financial stability.

Our perspective

Most bankability problems we see are not finance problems. They are sequencing problems. A team raises money before it has pinned down feedstock, offtake or the construction contract, and then asks the financing to paper over the gap. It cannot.

Our approach is founder-side. We bring operational experience from prior energy projects that reached completion, and we use it to check that every commercial, technical and financial dependency has an owner and a document behind it. That is what improves financeability and buildability on difficult projects: woody waste-to-fuel, agricultural waste-to-fuel, nuclear fuel refinement and similar infrastructure.

We would rather a developer hear about a missing dependency from us in month three than from a lender's counsel in month eighteen. Capital strategy, board leadership and company formation all follow from the same discipline: know what the lender will ask, and have the answer ready.

Sam

Working with Sharon Creek Ventures

If you are preparing a project for financing, our capital strategy, board leadership and venture studio services are built for energy founders, developers, boards and investors working through exactly this. Capital strategy covers how the project is financed. Board leadership puts operating experience at the governance table. The venture studio forms new energy companies. For a closer look at how financing advice fits into development, see our piece on project finance advisory for energy developers.

FAQ

What is a bankable project?

A bankable project is one that lenders and investors will finance because its revenues are predictable, its risks are allocated and its contracts are enforceable. The test is whether debt can be repaid with acceptable confidence from the project's own cash flows. Strong projected returns alone do not make a project bankable.

How is bankability different from financeability?

Bankability describes whether the project's structure is acceptable to lenders. Financeability describes whether the project can actually close funding on terms the sponsors can live with, including the right instruments and sequencing. In practice, you work on bankability to reach financeability.

What documents do lenders ask for first?

The offtake or project agreement is usually the critical one, followed by feasibility studies, FEED, environmental and social approvals, the financial model and evidence of committed equity. EXIM's published application guidelines list these items and add creditworthy counterparties committed to their contractual obligations.

Can a new technology be bankable?

Yes, but it takes more support. Lenders will not accept the risk that new technology fails to perform to commercial standards over the project life, so developers use proven providers, guarantees, insurance and sometimes government programs. DOE's LPO describes its role as a bridge to bankability for early-commercialization projects.

When should we start working on bankability?

At the start of development. The IRENA data on rejections for low readiness and poor financial planning shows that gaps found late are costly. Mapping dependencies and fixing offtake before approaching lenders keeps the options open.

Sources

Turn your energy visions into reality.

Bring Sharon Creek in when the project needs more than advice—when interconnects, contracts, capital, incentives, and execution all have to come together.

Start a conversation